I've heard all over the place that conservatives who disagree with abortion yet support the death penalty and the Iraq war are hypocrites. It's not so, and here's my simple reasoning: someone who receives the death penalty has been given a fair trial by a jury of their peers. And the death penalty is only recommended by the jury if it suits the crime. I don't support all wars, but I do support the Iraq war and the Afghanistan war, because the means justify the end -- freedom for the people of a country to choose their own government, mass graves that will no longer expand, rape and torture rooms that are out of operation. It's terrible that people have to die to accomplish that, but it is for a greater good.
In the case of abortion, on the other hand, there is no fair trial for an "fetus" by a jury of its peers. And if there was, it would have to be found innocent or incompetent to stand trial, because an unborn child can't willfully commit a crime (the only possible crime would be endangering the mother's health, and the "fetus" can't endanger its mother's health on purpose.) The only "greater good" that is accomplished by aborting a child is, by and large, convenience or an unblemished reputation.
So I don't think the issues of the Iraq war, the death penalty, and dismembering a "fetus" are even comparable at all.








<< Home